Potential cocoa substitute: Jackfruit seeds create chocolate aroma, say researchers

By Oliver Nieburg contact

- Last updated on GMT

Brands could look to roasted jackfruit seeds if cocoa demand outstrips supply, say researchers ©iStock/greenaperture
Brands could look to roasted jackfruit seeds if cocoa demand outstrips supply, say researchers ©iStock/greenaperture

Related tags: Fermentation

Jackfruit seeds are a waste product that can be fermented, roasted and converted to flour imparting a chocolate aroma, according to research.

The study published in the Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry​ earlier this year said jackfruit seeds could help ease potential cocoa shortages.

The research was conducted by Fernanda Papa Spada et al.​ from the University of São Paulo, the Technology College of Piracicaba, the Methodist University of Piracicaba and the University of Reading.

Bangladesh’s national fruit

jackfruit tree - wilaiwanphoto

Jackfruit is a large tropical fruit native to Southern India. It is found today in South America, Africa, Asia and Australia. Its seeds account for 15-18% of its total weight. Jackfruit is the national fruit of Bangladesh.

‘Similar to that of chocolate’

“For the first time, we found that after roasting, jackfruit seeds imparted an aroma similar to that of chocolate,”​ wrote the researchers.

They said the finding could help manufacturers meet demand for chocolate flavor should cocoa demand outstrip supply, adding the seeds could be an alternative revenue stream for Brazilian farmers.

“As with cocoa, the postharvest pretreatments and roasting of the jackfruit seeds are likely to influence the formation of these compounds and the quality of the aroma,” ​they wrote.

Postharvest processing similar to cocoa

To study the effects of postharvest treatment, the researchers developed 27 roasted jackfruit seed flours under different conditions similar to cocoa processing.

Each batch of seeds was either simply dried (dried jackfruit seeds), fermented and dried (fermented jackfruit seeds) or acidified (acidified jackfruit seeds).

The seeds were then tested under different roasting lengths and temperatures.

The researchers used 25 jackfruit collected from a single tree in the countryside of São Paulo, Brazil, between October 2013 and January 2014.

Fermented seeds with moderate roasting give best results

An untrained sensory panel of 162 people aged 18 to 54 evaluated the flours.

The researchers found the most sensory chocolate aroma in fermented flour (rather than acidified or only dried) subjected to moderate roasting conditions.

Box fermentation lasted 12 days, longer than cocoa fermentation (5 to 8 days) as jackfruit seeds are bigger than cocoa beans.

“Unfermented cocoa is very bitter and astringent with little apparent chocolate flavor, whereas the unfermented jackfruit flour (from dried jackfruit seeds) still had some chocolate aroma,”​ wrote the researchers.

Acidified jackfruit seeds had some chocolate aroma, but led to some negative descriptions from the sensory panel, such as ‘earthy’ and ‘rancid’.

Impact on color

The study team said jackfruit seeds had moisture, pH and color similar to cocoa.

They said seeds produced under the highest-temperature roast had a similar color or luminosity closest to cocoa powder.

However, manufacturers may need to modify color with other ingredients depending on the application, they said. 

The study was funded by the National Council of Technological and Scientific and Research Foundation (FAPESP).

Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry
DOI: 10.1021/acs.jafc.6b04836
‘Optimization of Postharvest Conditions To Produce Chocolate Aroma from Jackfruit Seeds’
Authors: Fernanda Papa Spada, Lais Masson Zerbeto, Gabriel Bernardes Cabreira Ragazi, Érika Maria Roel Gutierrez, Miriam Coelho Souza, Jane K. Parker, and Solange Guidolin Canniatti-Brazaca

Related topics: R&D, Chocolate, Cocoa & Sugar, Ingredients

Related news

Show more

Related products

show more

Better-for-you is better for business

Better-for-you is better for business

Valio | 20-Sep-2022 | Application Note

The challenge confronting chocolate and confectionery manufacturers is how to balance taste with consumers’ demand for confectionery that allows for indulgence...

Finding a sweet balance between health, indulgence

Finding a sweet balance between health, indulgence

Cargill | 09-Aug-2022 | Technical / White Paper

The confectionery category has had a wild ride the past couple of years. Amid the pandemic, consumers sought comfort in indulgence; now, they're looking...

Create sugar-less chocolate with Isomalt

Create sugar-less chocolate with Isomalt

BENEO | 10-May-2022 | Technical / White Paper

Almost 1 in 4 consumers in the US say the best way to control sugar intake is eating less sugar-full candy. But nobody likes to give up on a good tasting...