‘No palm oil’ label battle won’t start trade or court war: Malaysian minister

By Annie Harrison-Dunn contact

- Last updated on GMT

'No palm oil' labels are unfair, baseless and a deliberate effort to hinder the palm oil industry, says Malaysian minister.
'No palm oil' labels are unfair, baseless and a deliberate effort to hinder the palm oil industry, says Malaysian minister.

Related tags: Palm oil, International trade

The Malaysian government says it is assessing what action it should take to address ‘no palm oil’ labels in France and Belgium, the legal grounds for which have come under scrutiny.

Some French and Belgian food firms have taken to labelling products ‘no palm oil’ - something that sought to inform consumers who may want to avoid palm oil for environmental or perhaps health reasons. Yet legal experts say this could be in violation of EU law​ and pose a scientifically unjustified barrier to trade.

Meeting with European journalists as part of a week-long press trip around Malaysia organised by the Malaysian Palm Oil Council (MPOC), he said these labels were unfair, baseless and a deliberate effort to hinder the palm oil industry.

Yet he said dialogue, not counter trade barriers against EU exports or legal action, would be key in finding a solution for both sides and said they would continue to engage with the French and Belgian government to find a solution.  

sans palm
French supermarket Casino's own brand chocolate nut spread states "sans huile de palme" ('without palm oil'). 

Under the new EU Food Information for Consumers Regulation (FIC) which comes into force next week, all food products must state specifically the source of vegetable oils (i.e. palm, rapeseed, sunflower) on ingredient lists. This in itself would not single out palm from other oils – but Malaysia says ‘no palm oil’ labels went a step too far and insinuated the ingredient was something to be avoided.

Don’t forget – our trade is bilateral  

 “To us the issue is very critical. We have a lot of trade, two-way trade, with France so we hope both governments would understand that any [trade barrier] will not be in the interest of both countries. So we hope [the French government] will assist us to resolve some of those issues,” ​Uggah Embas, who previously held the position of environment minister, said.  

“Our agencies are looking at what the main course of action is. We hope we don’t have to resort to legal action. We hope with dialogue and discussion, more deliberation and understanding of palm oil we will be able to resolve these issues.”

Asked by a French journalist if Malaysia planned to retaliate against these labels by, for example, reducing the amount of Airbus aircraft purchases, the minister laughed off the idea and said he didn’t think it needed to reach this level.

“As much as you [France] are selling your Airbus to us and how this benefits your economy, we hope you also understand how important it is for you to buy our palm oil to help our economy, because if our economy is growing then we have money to buy your Airbus.”

According to the Malaysia External Trade Development Corporation (MATRADE), in 2013, Malaysia was the EU’s 29th largest export destination and 20th largest import source.

Malaysia’s total trade with the EU amounted to $43.1bn (€34.78bn) in 2013 - $20.7bn (€16.70bn) in exports from Malaysia to the EU and $22.4bn ($18.07bn) in imports from the EU to Malaysia. The major trading partners within this were Germany (29%), followed by the Netherlands (19.9%), France (13.9%), the UK (10.4%) and Italy (6.7%).

Continuing conversation

The minister was in Europe this week as part of a timber and palm oil promotion mission to the Netherlands – where most of the palm oil passes through - and Belgium. A delegation from the Belgian economic mission also came to Malaysia last month, where he said the label issue would be discussed over dinner.

The outcome of those discussions was unclear, but speaking ahead of the meeting in November the Malaysian minister said this formed part of an ongoing dialogue between itself and France and Belgium.

He said Malaysia had written to and visited the French government​ and that so far the feedback from that was positive.

Related news

Related products

show more

Finding a sweet balance between health, indulgence

Finding a sweet balance between health, indulgence

Cargill | 09-Aug-2022 | Technical / White Paper

The confectionery category has had a wild ride the past couple of years. Amid the pandemic, consumers sought comfort in indulgence; now, they're looking...

Create sugar-less chocolate with Isomalt

Create sugar-less chocolate with Isomalt

BENEO | 10-May-2022 | Technical / White Paper

Almost 1 in 4 consumers in the US say the best way to control sugar intake is eating less sugar-full candy. But nobody likes to give up on a good tasting...

Sugar-Free Doesn’t Have to Be Boring

Sugar-Free Doesn’t Have to Be Boring

Glanbia Nutritionals | 15-Mar-2022 | Product Brochure

The use of bright or unexpected colors to attract consumer’s attention online has created a market for colorful food and drinks that can “go viral”. EdiSparklz...